We Sherlockians all know that this quote originated with Sherlock himself in The Sign of Four. But, the Sherlock Holmes novels don’t exist in BBC Sherlock’s universe. So, for the longest time I just assumed that Sherlock came up with the phrase in The Hounds of Baskerville at The Cross Keys pub, and that John’s “Spock” comment was just poking fun that Sherlock was being overly analytical and needed to calm down.

However, then I obviously remembered that the phrase was actually said by Spock in the 2009 film Star Trek. And that The Hounds of Baskerville takes place in 2011.

So, assuming that BBC Sherlock exists in a universe in which Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and his stories don’t exist, Sherlock is actually quoting Spock (who coined the phrase) from the 2009 Star Trek film- not just coming up with something clever off the top of his head. And John recognizes that and calls him out on it. So this means that they’ve both seen the film. I’d wager that they saw it together. Sherlock doesn’t seem like much of a film buff, but he’d endure it if he saw it with John.

Meaning that at one point in time John and Sherlock had a Star Trek night.

That is all.

And John bought popcorn and threw bits of it at Sherlock anytime he started criticizing the plot over a low whisper. THIS HAPPENED, I FEEL IT



  1. larosadiversailles reblogged this from pretendsisterofsassy
  2. imajohnlocked reblogged this from ineffableboyfriends
  3. fabulousalien reblogged this from frauleinsallybowles
  4. nelehybhsa reblogged this from snawesomeredfox
  5. snawesomeredfox reblogged this from cumberbatchlookslikeallama
  6. rocktherebelmetalthedevilblog reblogged this from clearsn0w
  7. slightlyoffcolour reblogged this from swiggity-swag-at-221b
  8. swiggity-swag-at-221b reblogged this from mightevenbeagoodone and added:
    But what about the movie Star Trek VI:Undiscovered Country where Spock says “An ancestor of mine maintained that if you...
  9. fannishcodex reblogged this from argyleredhead
  10. aformofmotion reblogged this from frightfullytwee
  11. limegreendreammachine reblogged this from manafromheaven
  12. owlwinter reblogged this from sherlock10knotes
  13. thereisno-good-or-evil reblogged this from ladyveldy
  14. daeliciousss reblogged this from cumberbatchlookslikeallama
  15. bittercoffeebeans reblogged this from thatsjustpaint and added:
    Yes, but what happens when they see the sequel and notice that one of the characters looks rather familiar?
  16. hell-hounds-in-221b reblogged this from datatwohearts
  17. hartknyx reblogged this from dineru
  18. elpisandadris reblogged this from paradoxical-ferrets
  19. squish--squish reblogged this from tardiswanted
  20. safesexandkittens reblogged this from tardiswanted
  21. charlieinsidethetardis reblogged this from tardiswanted
  22. deducewho reblogged this from tardiswanted
  23. paradoxical-ferrets reblogged this from tardiswanted
  24. tardiswanted reblogged this from braveheartbecky
  25. random-fandom-blog reblogged this from starsdean
  26. majestic-space-duck reblogged this from sherlockspaddedroom
  27. ciel-noir17 reblogged this from isnotyoursextoy and added:
    I will always reblog this!
  28. isnotyoursextoy reblogged this from faeriviera
  29. sherlockianblainer reblogged this from ineffableboyfriends
  30. unblindedunlearnedunbridled reblogged this from spooooopernatural